Dec 2, 2011

End of Season Thoughts

Bill Bishop has some end of the year thoughts:
Postroute, Postroute.  You are like the old lover with whom we all had a brief but passionate fling.  I’m making a late season booty call.  I have some thoughts on the season:

1.      Now that everyone makes it to a bowl game and the January 1st games have been dispersed, Thanksgiving weekend is the best weekend in college football.  Rivalry games start early and run late.  This time around we have been treated to Texas/Texas A&M, Michigan/Ohio St., Clemson/South Carolina, Georgia/Georgia Tech, Pitt/West Virginia, Alabama/Auburn, Stanford/Notre Dame, Missouri/Kansas, FSU/Gators and a host of others.  For the last three days, I have been able to watch a good college football game whenever I wanted. 

2.      Missouri is joining the SEC, specifically the SEC East.  I’ve probably heard a thousand times recently, “We can compete in the East.”  Of course we can compete.  Win?  Georgia has ripped off ten straight wins and looks exactly like they were supposed to look in August.  They have more meat up front than your local butcher shop.  I’ve seen Spurrier in this position before.  One year he looks good, the next year he gets close, and then he kicks in the door leaving teams wondering what happened.  The Florida defense is stacked.  This is coming from a FSU alum.  Their offense is horrible, but they play SEC defense.  Vanderbilt just beat Wake Forest and was close enough to win every other one of their games except against Alabama.  The SEC is loaded for next year.  I could easily see Alabama, LSU, Arkansas, Georgia and South Carolina in the top ten at the start of the year.  Thank God for Kentucky.

3.   Michigan finishes the regular season at 10-2 with a win over Ohio State.  Somehow, that seems right.  Brady Hoke has done a remarkable job turning that program around and adding some respectability to the Big 10.  The Big 10 is always better when the Big Blue is doing well.  As a whole, the Big 10 has suffered through its most embarrassing season ever.  Scandals at Ohio State and Penn State have knocked the sheen off of the Big 10 in a way that one would not have imagined 12 months ago.  Football in the Big 10 seems normal again.  Indiana, Purdue and Minnesota are living at the bottom, Illinois had another inexplicable collapse that leaves you wondering if the coach will have a job come January, Iowa showed glimpses of really good football and settled for middle of the road, and the true conference power once again resides around the upper Great Lakes in Michigan and Wisconsin.  Oh yes, and no one even remembers if Northwestern suited up this season.

4.   I am not a fan of rematches in bowl games, especially in championship games.  I consider it a foregone conclusion that the BCS title game will be LSU vs. Alabama.  They are the best two teams out there, and it is apparent no one else wanted to play LSU so I guess we are stuck with it.  I envision another great defensive game in which the punter and place kicker are the most important players of the game.  My problem, though, is what will we have learned if Alabama wins?

5.   We need new rules for the PAC-12. The first rule should be that after a team makes its first 40 pass attempts, the clock no longer stops on incomplete pass plays.  PAC games last five hours because they pass the ball every play.  The second rule should be that every team is required to field an actual defensive unit.  Not 11 kids they borrowed from a local high school for the game, but honest to God real scholarship athletes who are instructed by real defensive coordinators.  I don’t know what defensive coordinators are actually paid in the PAC, but I know it is too much.  If a head coach in the PAC really wanted to win, they would go grab any SEC defensive coordinator, pay him a million dollars to recruit a defensive unit and then turn the kids loose on the field.  The other 11 teams would have no idea what hit them.  My third rule change for the PAC would be that if no team in a particular division was any good, two teams from the same division would get to play for the Championship.  Yes, that would violate my rematch aversion noted above, but anything would be better than watching the train wreck that will be Oregon vs. UCLA for the PAC championship.

6.   The best thing about conference realignment this season:  Missouri’s wrestling team will win the SEC championship next year, and every year for the foreseeable future.  After that, I’m not sure what college football as a whole has achieved.  It looks like things will settle down once the Big East works out a survival plan.  The PAC, Big 12, Big 10, SEC and ACC are set for now.  Television contracts in those conferences are pretty much set for a few years.  If the Big East can add a few, they, too will survive and get paid by the broadcasters.  I would love to see the smaller conferences (CUSA, MAC, MWC and WAC) form a 36 team super-conference.  They could institute a mini playoff with four divisions and the winner having a guaranteed BCS berth. That would be fun and they would have some clout to negotiate a good television deal.  That would settle things down a bit.

7.   I think that is about it.  I know a list of ten would be better, but I don’t have much more to say.  I have enjoyed this season of college football and look forward to the upcoming bowl games.  It has been a crazy season with a lot of parity.  Outside of the SEC, the conferences have been open for whichever team wanted to step up and win.  Mizzou beat Kansas.  FSU beat Miami and Florida, which is always good even if the games were meaningless outside of the state of Florida this year.  Thanks for taking my late night call Postroute.  I think I’ll go have a smoke now.


No comments:

Post a Comment